TRENDING

Sakeliga Drags ICASA to Court Over South Africa’s 30% Telecoms Ownership Rule: What a Win Means for Starlink and Foreign Operators

By: indexprima

November 21, 2026

Image Source: https://www.news24.com/business/tech/new-legal-challenge-over-bee-rule-thats-keeping-starlink-out-of-sa-20261112-0283

Share

A lobby group, Sakeliga, has asked a Pretoria court to overturn a ruling by South Africa’s telecoms regulator, ICASA. The ruling backs a rule that some licence holders must be 30% owned by disadvantaged groups.

The case could change how foreign operators such as Starlink enter the market. ICASA says it will oppose it.

Sakeliga filed its case in the High Court in Pretoria on 9 November 2026. It wants the court to set aside ICASA’s 13 May decision. In that decision, ICASA said it cannot fully follow Minister Solly Malatsi’s December 2025 policy direction without a change in the law. Sakeliga says Section 9(2)(b) of the Electronic Communications Act does not make 30% ownership the only path. It says ICASA can also accept investment in place of shares. These let a firm invest in skills, small business support and digital networks instead of selling shares. Sakeliga says it does not want all such rules removed. ICASA says the law needs at least 30% ownership by disadvantaged groups for individual licence holders. On 19 November, Sakeliga said ICASA will oppose the case. Starlink has struggled to get the licences it needs. Its parent, SpaceX, has resisted giving up 30% of its local business. No ruling has been made.

Item Detail
Applicant. Sakeliga, a lobby group.
Court. High Court, Pretoria. Filed 9 November 2026.
Respondents. ICASA, its chairman, a department head and Malatsi.
Decision challenged. ICASA’s 13 May 2026 ruling.
Main relief. A ruling that the Act sets no fixed 30% minimum.
Fallback. If the court backs ICASA, strike down Section 9(2)(b) to that extent.
ICASA’s stance. It will oppose the case.
Next step. ICASA’s record is due by 30 November, per TechCentral.
Not stated. ICASA’s grounds for opposing, and a hearing date.

The dispute began with a policy direction. In December 2025, Malatsi told ICASA to consider matching its ownership rules to the ICT Sector Code. The code allows other investment in place of shares. These are called EEIPs. Under these, a global firm invests in areas such as skills and small business support. It does not sell shares in its local unit. Policy directions do not bind ICASA. It must only weigh them. On 13 May, ICASA said the Act “requires a minimum 30% ownership by historically disadvantaged groups.” It said it must use the amended Sector Code in its licence rules. But “full alignment with all provisions of the Code” would need a change to the Act.

The legal fight turns on a few words. Section 9(2)(b) sets ownership of at least 30% by historically disadvantaged groups. It adds: “or such other conditions or higher percentage as may be prescribed.” Sakeliga says “such other conditions” gives ICASA room to accept other routes. It also says ICASA broke the Act’s duty to follow the ICT charter, and broke the empowerment law. It calls the decision irrational and says ICASA ignored factors such as broadband roll-out. If the court backs ICASA’s reading, Sakeliga wants Section 9(2)(b) struck down where it fixes 30% ownership without room for EEIPs. The Constitutional Court would have to confirm that.

Lucien Pierce of PPM Attorneys supports the 30% rule. He told TechCentral the case puts ICASA in a hard spot. He reads the section narrowly: ownership must stay at 30% or more. Yet he thinks Sakeliga’s main point is right on a strict reading. That point is that the empowerment law beats the telecoms law. A change to the Act would bring certainty, he says. If Sakeliga’s reading is right, ICASA’s decision was wrong in law. He rates the fallback as weaker. Spectrum is scarce, he notes, and the state already sets minimum ownership for mining licences. So he believes a similar telecoms rule would stand. He added that he had not studied every angle of the case.

The politics are sharp. Sakeliga opposes black empowerment rules. EWN describes it as a group founded by AfriForum. It also objects to EEIPs. It says a win would not scrap the rules but would “replace a racial quota with a racial handicap.” Those are its own words. Its CEO, Piet le Roux, says the case “forces Icasa to play their hand.” Once ICASA files its record, he says, “they can’t change it afterwards.” Spokesperson Anton Meijer says it would give firms facing “total exclusion” another route. The other side sees the rule as a core tool of change. Malatsi, a respondent, wrote the policy direction that Sakeliga cites. Yet Daily Maverick reports that he called empowerment compliance a legal must for spectrum and service licences. Deputy Minister Mondli Gungubele said at an event that “people don’t understand [when we] talk about multinational corporations.”

Starlink sits at the centre, though it is not a party. On 1 October, Daily Maverick reported that Starlink was still no closer to market access. SpaceX has sent ICASA written views on high-frequency bands for ground stations and user dishes. ICASA’s draft spectrum rules would also add a way to register foreign satellites. Under draft Regulation 28B(2), registering would not give a right to sell services in South Africa. It would not replace local licence duties. A bill to amend the telecoms law, tabled in April, does not relax the ownership rule. So a Sakeliga win would not hand Starlink a licence. It would change the legal options open to the regulator.

Our reading is that the court must answer one narrow question. Can ICASA accept something besides shares under the words “such other conditions”? If yes, ICASA would still need to decide whether to accept EEIPs, and on what terms. Sakeliga says firms that use them could pay more. If no, the matter may move to Parliament, which could amend the Act. Or it may go to the Constitutional Court. That is our reading, not a prediction.

Why it matters: Spectrum lets mobile and satellite firms add coverage and compete. South Africa wants more broadband, most of all in places with poor service. It also wants to speed up economic change. This case sets those two goals against each other. A win for Sakeliga could affect internet providers, broadcasters and network firms. A win for ICASA would leave it to lawmakers and keep the 30% rule. Either way, foreign and local investors will read the result as a signal.

What to watch next: whether ICASA files its record by 30 November, and what grounds it gives for opposing. Watch whether Malatsi, a respondent, backs Sakeliga’s reading or not. Watch for a hearing date in Pretoria. Watch whether Parliament moves to change the Act. Watch what SpaceX and other satellite firms tell ICASA. And watch whether any court-approved EEIP route leads to a licence for Starlink.


Sources: Victoria Fakiya, “South Africa’s 30% telecoms ownership rule challenged”, Techpoint Digest, 13 November 2026; TechCentral report on Sakeliga’s court application, November 2026; TechCentral report on ICASA opposing the case, 19 November 2026; TechCentral, lawyer Lucien Pierce on the 30% rule and Sakeliga’s case, November 2026; ICASA, “ICASA communicates its response to the Policy Direction on Broad Based Black Economic Empowerment”, 13 May 2026; EWN, “High-stakes legal showdown could shape future of Musk’s Starlink in SA”, 12 November 2026; Daily Maverick, “Starlink South Africa market access”, 1 October 2026.

 

A note for startup founders: Don’t practice on investors. Practice on AI first. RaiseReady by Index Prima is an AI fundraising simulator for African founders: upload your pitch deck, get a readiness score and face a tough AI investor before the real meeting. Find this post, and every post we publish, at raiseready.indexprima.com.

🕶 Relax!

Put your feet up and let us do the hard work for you. Sign up to receive our latest Intel directly in your inbox.

We’ll never send you spam or share your email address.
Find out more in our Privacy Policy.